The Best Seafood Delivery Services of 2023

We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation. Learn more.

PureFish seafood delivery — Photo: PureFish

Unless you live near a fishing town on the coast, getting access to flavorful, sustainably sourced seafood is likely a huge challenge. However, fisheries and online seafood companies are making it much easier to enjoy fresh, flavorful seafood by shipping monthly catches right to your doorstep. Cook up your favorite seafood dish with wild-caught salmon from Alaska, omega-rich trout, and even specialty products like squid whenever you want thanks to easy online ordering and speedy delivery.

The fish you might be tempted to buy from the grocery store has likely been out of the water for weeks, but these seafood delivery companies catch, freeze, and deliver your order within a matter of days. This allows the fish to retain all of its natural flavor, meaning your favorite seafood recipes will turn out even more delectable than ever. And while many large-scale fisheries use artificial preservatives, exploitative sourcing methods, and practices that damage important ecosystems in our oceans, all the companies in this story are committed to seafood sustainability. Every product is wild caught or sustainably farmed, free from artificial ingredients, and protects the earth's long-term seafood supply. Whether you're craving grilled shellfish, slow-roasted salmon, or a formal lobster dinner, keep reading to find the best delivery services who make it even easier to enjoy your favorite seafood dishes.

Best Seafood Delivery Services of 2023

Best Overall: Sizzlefish
Best for Fresh Salmon: Alaskan Salmon Company
Best for Small Orders: Sea to Table
Best Wild-Caught Seafood: PureFish
Best for Shellfish: Fulton Fish Market
Best for Seafood Recipes: Oshen
Best for Lobster: LobsterAnywhere
Best for Meal Prepping: Crowd Cow
Best for Meat and Seafood: Good Chop

Best Overall: Sizzlefish

seafood delivery — Courtesy of Sizzlefish

Buy Now

Why We Chose It
With a plethora of sustainable fish options, you will enjoy selecting and building the perfect box or choosing from a curated bundle. If you need dinner inspiration, Sizzlefish's website includes dozens of free seafood recipes geared towards a variety of diets, such as Keto, paleo, and gluten-free.

Pros

Individual portion sizes
Free shipping on orders over $100
New online recipes added weekly
Helpful customer service

Cons

Does not ship on weekends

Unlike most frozen seafood, whose freezing and distribution process can take several days, all of Sizzlefish's fish are flash-frozen within a few hours of being caught. This allows the seafood that arrives on your doorstep to retain its full flavor, tasting just as good as you might expect from seafood fresh off the boat. Sizzlefish's extensive menu offers a huge selection of ethically sourced seafood, including salmon, halibut, shrimp, lobster, and more. All of the products are free from artificial ingredients, and a majority of the fish are caught in the wild (though some are raised in environmentally friendly farms or hatcheries). Sign up for a Sizzlefish Prime or Prime Plus box and choose your own items from the menu, or try the Wild Seafood Favorites box, which sends you a curation of wild-caught or hatchery raised seafood and shellfish every month. Food & Wine readers can also receive an exclusive discount at checkout by using the code FW10 for 10% off their first purchase.

To buy: Sizzlefish subscription, from $120 per box at sizzlefish.com

Best for Fresh Salmon: Alaskan Salmon Company

Buy Now

Why We Chose It
If you love sushi-grade salmon or you're interested in beefing up your omega-3 intake, then you will like customizing your Alaskan Salmon Company box. Founded by an Alaskan sea captain, the salmon is fished by a family fishing operation in Alaska. The fish is wild-caught and hand-cleaned, then vacuum-sealed and shipped overnight straight to your doorstep. You can also select from a variety of white fish options, such as black cod, halibut, and rockfish.

Pros

Restaurant-quality fish
Works directly with local fisherman
Flash-frozen for three days to ensure freshness and safety

Cons

Boxes can be expensive

As one of the most popular types of seafood, salmon can be found in abundance at most grocery stores and online retailers, but the quality and flavor can vary drastically. Instead, receive sushi-grade salmon used by Michelin-star restaurants with a subscription to Alaskan Salmon Company. Alaskan Salmon Company is trusted by some of the most famous seafood restaurants in the country, including Nobu, Sushi Ogawa, and others. All the fish in your order are wild-caught, cut by hand, then flash-frozen and shipped to your address, so everything you receive is bursting with flavor. You can also select your delivery frequency, so you only receive new orders of seafood when you need it.

To buy: Alaska Salmon Company subscription, from $189 per box at aksalmonco.com

Best for Small Orders: Sea to Table

Buy Now

Why We Chose It
With traceability at its core, Sea to Table takes pride in informative labeling so you can know where your fish came from and how the fish was caught. With several ordering options, it's easy to sneak in your weekly dose of seafood. Select from several combo boxes for pre-selected seafood, such as the "Pescatarian Pack" featuring Gulf of Maine redfish, Northwest Pacific cod, and West Coast Dover sole. If you're not looking to fill your freezer with fish, you can order seafood à la carte in smaller and more manageable portions, like tins of tuna or wild Gulf shrimp.

Pros

All fish is wild-caught in U.S. waters
Excellent traceability transparency
Can order without creating an account
30-day, 100% satisfaction guarantee

Cons

$99 minimum to unlock free shipping

This family owned seafood business eliminates the guesswork behind knowing where the fish you purchased was caught and how long it's been out of water by using special tracking software. Each package includes a traceability label with information on where the seafood was caught, the catching method, and the best-by date, making it easy to ensure your order is fresh, ethically sourced, and delicious. In addition to full-size seafood boxes like the Salmon Lover's Box and the Sushi-Maki Box, Sea to Table also offers two-serving packs that you can purchase and have delivered on a recurring basis. You can alter your shipping date, update delivery frequency, and switch items in your order anytime, so there's always an opportunity to try something new.

To buy: Sea to Table seafood, from $13 for two servings at sea2table.com

Best Wild-Caught Seafood: PureFish

Buy Now

Why We Chose It
With custom boxes like "The Grill Box," featuring Arctik salmon hot dogs and Caribbean Cobia burgers, your next barbeque night will be a cinch with PureFish. Simply cook your seafood in the accompanying packaging right on your grill. If you're looking for a more elevated experience, you can purchase the "Caviarchi Caviar" box, complete with a 50-gram jar of sustainably-sourced sturgeon for your next caviar and Champagne soiree.

Pros

Oven-ready seafood
Free shipping
Unique spice pack add-ons
Boxes curated by dietician with nutrition notes

Cons

16 portions per order

Enjoy salmon caught in the Arctic Circle, scallops from the North Atlantic Ocean, and shrimp from the Pacific Coast of Mexico with sustainably harvested seafood from PureFish. All of the seafood in every PureFish order is caught in the wild or raised using environmentally friendly fishing practices, which ensures that fish populations don't get depleted and the ecosystems they live in remain balanced. PureFish's high-quality seafood cuts arrive in portioned, oven-safe trays so you can season your fish and pop it into the oven for a quick, delicious dinner. Sign up for one of five boxes, including the Omega Box, Rainbow Box, Custom Box, or the Grill Box for eight trays of seafood, or try the Petite Box to save space in your freezer.

To buy: PureFish subscription, from $107 per box at purefish.com

Best for Shellfish: Fulton Fish Market

Why We Chose It
With an immense selection of seafood, you can enjoy restaurant-quality fish on your terms. If you love crustaceans, then you will appreciate the shellfish options, including Red King crab claws, sea scallops, and lobster tails.

Pros

Subscriptions have great customization options
Recyclable packaging

Cons

Some customers complain of shipping issues

One of the oldest fish markets in the United States, Fulton Fish Market is a New York City-based seafood hub made up of family-owned fish wholesalers who catch and sell sustainable seafood to customers. You don't have to live in Manhattan to reap the benefits, though; Fulton Fish Market's website offers tons of seafood to order, including a huge selection of shellfish and several subscription packages. You can choose how often you want your boxes delivered (weekly, biweekly, monthly, or bimonthly) and cancel whenever you want.

To buy: Fulton Fish Market subscription, from $65 per box at fultonfishmarket.com

Best for Seafood Recipes: Oshen

Buy Now

Why We Chose It
From ocean to table, Oshen delivers sustainably-raised salmon from the waters of Chile, managing and overseeing the entire life cycle of the fish. And if salmon is your fish of choice, then you will love the gourmet, mouth-watering recipes, such as sweet honey salmon with roasted sweet potatoes or salmon tartare with avocado and toasted sesame.

Pros

Individually-wrapped portions
Company practices sustainable aquaculture
Fisheries are well-managed
Options for fresh or frozen salmon

Cons

Some shipping may take up to 4 business days

Enjoy sustainably raised salmon from cold-water fjords in Southern Chile with a subscription to Oshen. This seafood company runs on renewable energy and works closely with its fishermen to ensure the salmon in every box is packed with protein and Omega-3s. Instead of freezing the fish after catching, Oshen puts them in temperature-controlled coolers and ships them directly to you. Because of this, the fish you receive is guaranteed to be at least seven days fresher than your local seafood retailer. Choose between Oshen's four boxes: the One Night Stand, which comes with eight ounces of Atlantic Salmon; the Entertainer box, which includes two 2.5-pound salmon filets; or the Oshen's Twelve box, which includes 12 six-ounce portions that are perfect for entertaining (or restocking the freezer). You can also browse the Oshen website to find delectable seafood recipes, such as salmon cakes, salmon ceviche, and more.

To buy: Oshen subscription, from $68 per week at oshensalmon.com

Best for Lobster: LobsterAnywhere

Buy Now

Why We Chose It
Break out your lobster bib, because you can have fresh-caught lobsters from Maine's famed coast delivered to your door. Since 1999, LobsterAnywhere has been delivering fresh, frozen, and live lobsters right to your home, so you can have a lobster dinner without going on a New England getaway.

Pros

Earn reward points towards discounts
Great gift options
Free overnight shipping

Cons

Boxes are expensive
Shipping is not available for major holidays

Even if you don't live along the coast, you can still enjoy fresh, restaurant-quality lobster thanks to LobsterAnywhere. The locally caught seafood from this New England-based fishing wholesaler is taken fresh off Maine fishing boats, hand-selected by a team of seafood experts, and delivered to you within a matter of days. Purchase live lobster, frozen lobster meat, fresh shrimp, sea scallops, or specialty seafood with just a few clicks, and sign up for rewards to earn discounts on future orders. You can also try LobsterAnywhere's chowders, bisques, and surf and turf dinners to make your meal complete.

To buy: Lobster Dinner, from $119 at lobsteranywhere.com

Best for Meal Prepping: Crowd Cow

Buy Now

Why We Chose It
Crowd Cow makes it easy to feed a family (or crowd) thanks to the custom boxes filled with ready-to-heat proteins and sides. An email is sent before your package is shipped, so you can have final say in the curated box. If you're looking for a seafood-centric box, you can choose from over 50 sustainably-sourced seafood items. Every item online comes with a thorough description, including tasting notes, cooking instructions, and fishery information.

Pros

Search filters include the fishery or farm
Geographically-traceable seafood
Weekly deals

Cons

Must spend $125 to unlock free shipping

For quick and easy seafood meals, Crowd Cow minimizes the effort it takes to get dinner on the table by providing flavorful fish from best-in-class producers in one convenient package. This meat and seafood delivery company has several subscription boxes geared toward simple dinners, including protein and veggie bundles, fully-prepped seafood, and family-size packs that cut down on your time in the kitchen. Sign up for a seafood-only subscription, which includes lobster tails, salmon, trout, sea scallops, and shrimp, or create a custom box and fill it with any combination of meat and fish from Crowd Cow's menu. In addition to sourcing seafood from sustainable, fair trade fishers, all of Crowd Cow's packaging is 100% recyclable and compostable, minimizing your order's impact on the environment.

To buy: Best of Seafood box, from $87 per box at crowdcow.com

Best for Meat and Seafood: Good Chop

Buy Now

Why We Chose It
If surf and turf is your idea of a perfect meal, then sampling Good Chop may be a winning combination. No need to subscribe to a separate butcher subscription and a seafood delivery box; instead, you can have fun mixing and matching your favorite proteins, which are sustainably-sourced from the U.S. Now you can dream about your next special date night at home with a plate full of Wagyu beef and Norwegian Atlantic salmon.

Pros

Menu rotates regularly
Customize box up to 5 days before shipping
Flexible delivery schedules

Cons

Boxes start at $149

Enjoy flavorful cuts of seafood, chicken, pork, and beef in one convenient location with Good Chop. This online butcher shop offers responsibly raised and sourced meat and seafood that's free of artificial ingredients, added hormones, antibiotics, and preservatives. All of Good Chop's seafood comes from fisheries that have been certified by the Marine Stewardship Council, which works to restore wild fish populations and minimize harm to local ecosystems. Create your own fully customizable subscription box by choosing your favorite proteins from options like salmon, rockfish, cod, beef, pork, and chicken.

To buy: Good Chop subscription, from $149 per box at goodchop.com

Final Verdict

Sizzlefish gets our nod for best overall seafood delivery service. For over 30 years, Sizzlefish has been sourcing high-quality, fresh fish. We like that you can compare plans, making it easy to select the best plan for you and your family. The company touts an informative blog filled with resources and nutrition information, ranging from topics about seafood health benefits and fish oil usage to how best to incorporate more seafood into your diet. Customers also rave about the helpful customer service team and reliable packaging, mentioning that fish always arrives frozen despite any weather issues.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Do Seafood Subscription Boxes Work?

Seafood subscription boxes function in a variety of ways. Some services let you take the reins and customize your boxes, selecting whatever strikes your fancy, while other services curate your boxes, sending you a shipment of preselected fish hand-picked by the fishmonger. Many sites offer details on where your fish was caught or farmed, as well as tasting notes and guidelines. Certain seafood subscription boxes even include recipes to help spark delicious dinner ideas. Depending on the service, you can typically select your box by size, frequency, and even seafood type. After you've submitted your payment information, get ready for your seafood subscription box to arrive within a few days, which should give you plenty of time to get your cast iron skillet seasoned and your grill fired up.

Are Seafood Subscriptions Boxes Worth it?

Unless you're a born angler or live near the coast, obtaining dock-to-door, fresh seafood can be challenging. If you're a pescatarian or simply love shellfish and seafood, investing in a seafood delivery service can be a great benefit for you and your family. In general, fish is a wonderful addition to your diet, so adding more seafood into your weekly meals may increase health benefits. And if you select a service that curates the fish for you, you have an opportunity to try something special and unique. Some seafood delivery companies let you pick and choose your proteins, so if you are craving a lobster bake and can't get to Maine on the fly, finding a company that ships lobsters can offer a decadent crustacean treat that.

How Much Do Seafood Subscription Boxes Cost?

Depending on the size of your box and the number of seafood products you order, the prices will vary. Some seafood subscription services focus on smaller portions of fish and cost about $15 a portion. Other boxes are larger, more geared towards feeding a crowd, or keeping your freezer full. For larger shipments, costs can range from around $65 to $100 or even more.

What Kind of Seafood is Available in a Seafood Subscription Box?

All sorts! With so many fish in the sea, your options are just about limitless. Some seafood subscription boxes handpick a variety of fish for you to try, while other companies specialize in a specific type, such as wild Alaskan salmon or live lobsters from the New England coast. There are even subscription boxes that have both seafood and meat, so you don't have to choose between surf and turf. With ecosystems fraught and waters overfished, many reliable seafood subscription companies focus on sourcing sustainably-farmed or wild seafood, working directly with fisheries and fisherman, so you can feel better about where your meals are coming from.

Methodology

Our team of researchers independently reviewed dozens of online seafood delivery subscription services in order to make our selections. Some of the criteria included price, membership details, shipping fees, types of products available, sourcing information, customer service options, and delivery times, with the goal of delivering a list of seafood subscription services that fit a variety of needs and budgets.

Updated by

Marisa Olsen

Was this page helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!

Tell us why!