carbon steel skillet

Even Chefs Are Swapping Le Creuset and All-Clad for This Carbon Steel Skillet That's 42% Off at Amazon

“This pan is the most like my pro pans than anything I’ve ever used.”
By Amy Schulman
September 12, 2021
Each product we feature has been independently selected and reviewed by our editorial team. If you make a purchase using the links included, we may earn commission.

While it's likely your kitchen is stocked with a fleet of stainless steel skillets or handy nonstick pans, you might not be as familiar with working on a surface like carbon steel, the lovechild of cast iron and classic nonstick. If you're already a cast iron lover, then you're definitely going to want to pull out a carbon steel pan and experiment with this beloved surface. 

For those just getting started with carbon steel, look to the top-rated de Buyer Mineral B Carbon Steel Frying Nonstick Pan, which starts at just $29 at Amazon. The skillet is forged from 99% iron and 1% carbon, making it super slick—without relying on synthetic coatings. Once the skillet has been seasoned with a neutral oil, the pan will become even more nonstick over time, a perfect vessel for searing everything from steaks and fried eggs to chicken and tofu. Plus it's free of toxins like PTFE and PFOA.  

The super thick skillet boasts excellent heat retention and is oven safe up to 400 degrees Fahrenheit. It's finished off with a riveted handle that won't loosen over time, one that also is designed with an ergonomic curve ideal for sautéing, stirring, and flipping. 

To buy: de Buyer Mineral B Carbon Steel Frying Nonstick Pan, $29 (originally $50) at amazon.com

The skillet has earned nearly 8,000 five-star ratings from shoppers who say it's "better than cast iron" and "evenly holds the heat forever." Even cooks who have sworn by cast iron their entire life are impressed, with one writing, "I love my Lodge cast iron, it gives me great steaks, but de Buyer carbon steel pan is far-far away better."

"This was my first foray into carbon steel and I am in love," one five-star reviewer shares. "I did a single seasoning pass with basic vegetable oil and then cooked a fried egg which, to my astonishment, slid around the pan effortlessly. I've since cooked numerous other meals in this pan and love it more with each use. I can't believe I've gone my whole life spending far more money on supposedly 'lifetime' nonstick pans that inevitably fail no matter how careful I am with them. If you prepare and use this pan correctly, it is an insanely good value."

"I'm spoiled and have had the 'best of the best' pans for as long as I can remember: All Clad, Calphalon, Lodge, Le Creuset, etc," another user says. "I've also worked in pro kitchens. This pan is the most like my pro pans than anything I've ever used. It transfers heat so incredibly well. I cooked a perfect steak on the first try."

Change the way you cook by picking up a de Buyer Mineral B Frying Carbon Steel Nonstick Pan while it's just $29 at Amazon.