Crowd Cow Review 2023: Is the Meat Delivery Service Worth Your Money?

Learn more about the pricing, product offerings, and optional memberships.

We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation. Learn more.

Crowd Cow box in a kitchen
Photo: Crowd Cow

Meat should always be a showstopper when you're preparing it as a main course, no matter if you're grilling, frying, smoking, roasting, or slow cooking it. If you want to achieve restaurant-worthy results, it's important to buy top-quality meat. Some grocery stores carry premium proteins, but there's a much easier way to ensure your meat is sustainably raised and packed with flavor. Enter Crowd Cow's meat delivery service.

There are many perks to ordering meat online. You get to browse the product pages from the comfort of your home, order many different types of meat at once, and receive deliveries large enough to last you all month long. On Crowd Cow's website, you can either shop a la carte or become a member to score free shipping on $149+ and 5% off every order. If you eat meat several times a week, the Crowd Cow subscription is the way to go. Plus, you have complete control over your shipments if you need to skip, cancel, or adjust orders. In other words, it's super flexible to fit your lifestyle.

Pros

  • Huge selection of meat and seafood
  • Grass-fed, free-range, pasture-raised, wild-caught, and organic proteins
  • Flexible and customizable subscription options
  • Exclusive discounts for members

Cons

  • More expensive than grocery store prices
  • Doesn't offer plant-based meat substitutes
Crowd Cow review
Courtesy of Crowd Cow

What Is Crowd Cow?

Crowd Cow is an online meat delivery service that partners with ethical farms and fisheries to supply the freshest food possible. Not only does the Crowd Cow team carefully select their producers, but they also taste test all of the products before making them available to customers. These standards ensure you're receiving sustainably raised meat and seafood that doesn't lack quality or flavor.

Crowd Cow offers meats you don't always see in grocery stores, like Japanese Wagyu and game meats, as well as everyday proteins, such as free-range chicken, grass-fed beef, and heritage pork. Customers claim their deliveries go beyond expectations with shoppers saying, "NO comparison to store-bought meat," and "melt-in-your-mouth good." Five-star reviewers rave about the flavor, texture, packaging, service, and the fact they know where their meat comes from.

Signing Up for Crowd Cow: How It Works

You don't have to be a Crowd Cow member to shop the site. However, signing up comes with perks. Subscribers save 5% on every item in each order, score free shipping whenever they spend $149 or more, and get exclusive access to new products and discounts. Tip: If you refer someone to Crowd Cow, both of you earn a $25 credit to your accounts.

Crowd Cow Meat Options

Crowd Cow offers a wide selection of meat and seafood. The extensive list includes beef and Wagyu (ground beef and steaks), bison, chicken and turkey (breasts, thighs, wings, whole birds, and more), duck and game meat, pork (bacon, chops, roasts, and sausage), and seafood (salmon, lobster, shrimp, and scallops).

Crowd Cow's easy-to-navigate website makes buying meat online a straightforward task. You can browse bestsellers, specific cuts of meat, butcher specials, and new arrivals. If you're curious about the family farms, you can head to their page to learn more about their practices and then purchase products from there. There are also non-meat options to add to your cart, including sides, desserts, and seasonings. With so many great products to choose from, it's fair to say reaching the $149 free shipping threshold for members isn't hard to do.

To get your first order underway, simply create an account by entering your email address and a password. Finish setting up your account's basic information, like your phone number and zip code, and then the fun begins—building your box. Select as many or as few food items as you'd like, including meat, seafood, sides, and desserts.

Crowd Cow review
Courtesy of Crowd Cow

Crowd Cow Pricing

Like all products, when it's higher quality, it tends to be more expensive. Crowd Cow's prices are likely higher than your local grocery store's, but the company is also providing you with grass-fed, free-range meat from independent farmers as well as responsibly caught seafood from some of the best waters around the world.

The bestsellers list mostly features a variety of steak, poultry, and seafood, with prices starting at $7. For typical monthly orders, you can expect to see free-range ground turkey for $7 per pound, 12 ounces of Norwegian Atlantic salmon for less than $16, and a 12-ounce New York strip steak for about $20. If you want to splurge on a Wagyu bone-in ribeye, it costs about $100 for 1 pound.

Several top-selling meats are on sale exclusively for members right now, so keep an eye out for deals—perhaps on Wagyu if you're lucky. Overall, Crowd Cow's pricing is similar to most online meat delivery services and comparable to organic grocers, like Whole Foods, that sell premium meats.

Crowd Cow Packaging and Delivery

You can bring reusable bags to grocery stores, but you can't control how online orders are packaged. Luckily, Crowd Cow uses 100% recyclable and compostable packing materials for every delivery. The big cardboard boxes can be recycled curbside, while the biodegradable foam can dissolve in your backyard compost bin or under warm water in your kitchen sink.

Crowd Cow deliveries are shipped frozen and available anywhere in the U.S. except for Hawaii and Alaska. Once you place your order, you'll receive a confirmation email with tracking information. You can also sign up for text message notifications to make sure you are up to date with your order status.

Crowd Cow Reviews and Customer Service

If you have a question, the help center and FAQ pages are great resources. They answer questions about signing up, products, payments, delivery processes, and other important information. To speak to a customer care team member, you can either email moo@crowdcow.com or text (206) 539-0639. There is also a live chat on Crowd Cow's website.

"Crowd Cow provides exceptional service. Their website is up to date with their latest inventory," one five-star reviewer wrote on Trustpilot. "They provide details on the ranches and farms you are purchasing from so you know what you're receiving and from where… As a first time customer, I was very impressed with the service, quality, and professionalism. I will continue to purchase from Crowd Cow in the future to support them and local ranches."

However, not every customer has been happy with their deliveries. One three-star reviewer noted, "I have ordered from Crowd Cow several times and have never been disappointed until this delivery. Their pork, beef, chicken, and scallops have been excellent. This time I added Wild Icelandic Red Fish (ocean perch) and Wild Icelandic Wolf Fish based on their descriptions as mild tasting and sweet. Neither lived up to their description."

Who's This Service Good For?

Crowd Cow is for people who love to cook and eat premium meats. I would recommend a membership to those who value sustainably sourced meat and seafood as well as preparing quality meals at home. If you love to host friends and family, this meat delivery service provides everything you need to serve hungry guests.

Who Isn't It Good For?

I wouldn't recommend Crowd Cow to people who prefer to buy cheap meat in stores and who aren't interested in how or where their meat is sourced. This service isn't for those who don't value ethically raised and wild-caught animal products.

The Bottom Line

Crowd Cow is a much more convenient way to shop for quality meats and it allows you to try options you may not have access to at your local grocery stores. The online butcher shop is easy to navigate and offers nice discounts. Most importantly, you're told exactly where your meat and seafood is coming from so that you can make the best choices for you and your family.

Was this page helpful?
Related Articles