Best Cheese Subscription Boxes

Murray’s Cheese is our pick for the best cheese subscription box

We independently research, test, review, and recommend the best products—learn more about our process. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.

Cheese Grotto's cheeses and Murray's Cheese
Photo: Cheese Grotto; Murray's Cheese

If you've become the friend who assembles a cheese board for every social gathering or casual evening at home, a monthly subscription that sends you artisan cheeses probably sounds like a dream. In reality, cheese subscription boxes are a delicious and easy way to switch up your palate—whether you can name every type of cheese in the grocery aisle or not.

As you begin sampling, you'll have the chance to learn about different flavor profiles, the history behind your favorite cheeses, and how to create the perfect pairing with wine, chocolate, or charcuterie. There are thousands of cheeses to explore—and new cheeses being invented all the time—so a subscription is truly the gift that keeps on giving.

Here are some of the best cheese subscriptions to whet your appetite, including monthly boxes focused on different regions across the globe, memberships that offer both wine and cheese, and more.

The Best Cheese Subscription Boxes of 2022

Best Overall: Murray's Cheese

Cheese Subscription Box
Courtesy of Murray's

Why We Chose It

Renowned New York City cheese shop Murray's Cheese gives customers nationwide access to its impressive selection of cheeses through its variety of home subscription boxes.

Pros

  • Variety of high-quality artisanal cheeses
  • Mix of classic and unusual cheeses
  • Free shipping

Cons

  • No customization options

Murray's Cheese has several monthly subscriptions to choose from. The renowned New York City cheese shop makes its own cheeses, but also hand-selects products from international and domestic vendors. The most popular memberships send you three to four different cheeses each month. The Classic Cheese of the Month Club is great for aspiring turophiles while the Cheesemonger's Picks subscription features bold flavors and textures that'll appeal to more adventurous cheese lovers. Murray's even ventures into mac and cheese territory, offering a Mac and Cheese of the Month membership that includes flavors like buffalo chicken, French onion, and truffle.

To buy: From $62 per month; murrayscheese.com

Best Wine and Cheese Pairings: Harry & David

Cheese Subscription Box
Courtesy of Harry and David

Why We Chose It

Harry & David may be known for its gift baskets, but its wine and cheese pairing club is ideal for those who want to enjoy a glass of wine that complements their fromage.

Pros

  • Cheese from renowned creameries around the world
  • Prospective subscribers can view monthly selections prior to purchasing
  • Can select starting up to one month in advance

Cons

  • Shipping not included

If you prefer to sample cheeses with a glass of wine in hand, you'll appreciate this Harry & David subscription. Well known for its wide selection of gift baskets, the brand also operates a wine and cheese pairing club, which features Harry & David-crafted wines and gourmet cheeses from renowned creameries all over the world. Try a sweet, buttery manchego while sipping pinot noir or an aged white cheddar with cabernet sauvignon. You can sign up for a three-month, six-month, or 12-month subscription.

To buy: $110 for a three-month subscription; harryanddavid.com

Best for Vermont Cheese

Jasper Hill Farms cheese
Courtesy of Jasper Hill Farms

Why We Chose It

Jasper Hill Farm offers subscriptions of its award-winning Vermont cheeses produced at its on-site creamery.

Pros

  • Made with milk from pasture-raised cows
  • Subscribers get access to special release cheeses
  • Also comes with cheese accompaniments, tools, and unique merchandise

Cons

  • No discount when subscribing for multiple months
  • No monthly payment plan option when buying multiple months

Made with milk from pasture-raised cows and aged in underground cellars, the cheeses in this subscription box are the real deal. Jasper Hill Farm, situated in Greensboro, Vermont, uses a traditional French cheesemaking approach called affinage, which involves a high level of precision and care to maintain the quality and incredible taste of the cheeses it produces. The dairy farm's monthly cheese subscription box comes with at least three different hand-cut cheeses, cheese tools, and other products to help you fully enjoy the selections. Plus, your monthly order may include special-release cheeses and limited availability items that are exclusive to subscribers.

To buy: $100 for a one-month subscription; jasperhillfarm.com

Best for International Cheeses: iGourmet

Cheese Subscription Box
Courtesy of igourmet

Why We Chose It

iGourmet features a variety of cheese subscriptions from Italy and France as well as an International Cheese Subscription Box and Platinum Cheese Subscription Box that showcases three unique cheeses from different countries around the world.

Pros

  • Multiple subscription and payment options available
  • Includes range of classic and rare cheeses
  • Shipping included
  • Can pause or cancel at any time

Cons

  • Does not come with any extra accompaniments

It'll be hard for you to pick just one of iGourmet's international cheese subscriptions. The boxes, which are great for people who are new to gourmet cheeses, not only include samples, but also educate recipients about various cheese types, taste profiles, and delicious pairings. Sign up for the French cheese subscription that showcases different regions of France or try the Italian curation for a taste of Piedmont, Tuscany, and Umbria. Each box comes with three half-pound cut cheeses to enjoy and a newsletter that guides you through the history of each one.

To buy: From $52 per month; igourmet.com

Best Cheese Gift Baskets: Mouth

Cheese Subscription Box
Courtesy of Mouth

Why We Chose It

Online gourmet marketplace Mouth has a monthly cheese subscription with a selection of three cheeses and a cheese accompaniment.

Pros

  • Mix of cheeses in each box from small batch producers around the country
  • Monthly payment plan available
  • Gourmet accompaniment to enjoy with the cheeses
  • Shipping included

Cons

  • Only two subscription plans available
  • Can't view cheese selections in advance

Honestly, a basket of cheese is an ideal gift for anyone who loves dairy. Mouth's monthly subscription box features three American cheeses from small-batch sellers and a tasty accompaniment (such as crackers or jam) to pair it with. Sign up for a three- or six-month subscription to begin receiving samples of tangy aged cheddar made in Vermont or tart goat cheese from Indiana. Each box includes information about the cheesemakers who contributed to that month's selection, so you can easily find and order your favorites again. Plus, you can shop for single-order cheeses, cheese board accessories, and other artisan food items on Mouth's website.

To buy: From $76 per month; mouth.com

Best for Rare Cheeses: Gourmet Cheese of the Month Club

Cheese Subscription Box
Courtesy of Cheese Month Club

Why We Chose It

The Gourmet Cheese of the Month Club features a selection of three international cheeses in each shipment for its Original Gourmet Cheese Club program. Want hard-to-find varieties? Try the Rare Cheese Club, which sources unique and unusual cheeses directly from cheesemakers.

Pros

  • Gives subscribers access to unique cheeses from lesser-known artisanal producers
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
  • Cheese is freshly cut to order

Cons

  • Shipping not included
  • No accompaniments to pair with the cheese

Every shipment from Gourmet Cheese of the Month Club contains three different hand-cut artisan or farmhouse cheeses made with natural ingredients. The Rare Cheese Club membership includes limited-production offerings, such as extended-aged and fresh cheeses that can only be made in a few locations around the world. Each cheese is cut on the same day it's shipped, and every box has a newsletter with detailed tasting notes, cheese profiles, cheesemaker histories, and serving and pairing suggestions.

To buy: From $39 per month; cheesemonthclub.com

Best for American Artisan Cheeses: Cheese Grotto

Cheese Subscription Box
Courtesy of Cheese Grotto

Why We Chose It

Cheese Grotto offers an immersive experience into American cheesemaking, including an invitation to an exclusive digital session with a featured cheesemaker as part of each quarterly shipment.

Pros

  • Each shipment includes a good mix of cheese styles
  • Includes supplemental literature and virtual access to cheesemaker
  • Free cancellation at any time

Cons

  • Shipping not included
  • No option for monthly delivery/only one subscription type

This quarterly cheese subscription sends you a variety of American-made cheeses to try, and it also teaches you how to store, serve, and pair them. Each shipment highlights a specific American cheesemaker and features styles such as bloomy and natural rind cheeses, blue cheese, and goat cheese from states including New York, Wisconsin, and Vermont. You can also purchase Cheese Grotto's namesake tool, which will keep your samples fresh for weeks or even months.

To buy: $62 per month; cheesegrotto.com

Final Verdict

Murray's is our pick for best overall because of its long standing company history and expertise in curating a selection of the best cheeses in the U.S. and around the world. Particularly convenient is the fact that the company boasts of a variety of subscription options, ensuring you will find the the best fit. The extra accompaniments and literature in each delivery are also an added bonus. Murray's Cheese of the Month Clubs are equally great as a gift or as a way for any cheese lover to have access to high-quality cheeses year round. As an added bonus, a Murray's subscription offers free shipping.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Are the Benefits to Subscribing to a Cheese of the Month Club?

Subscribing to a cheese of the month club is a great way to try cheeses that aren't available at a local supermarket while gaining access to specialty cheeses that are in limited production. Cheese of the month clubs typically come with supplemental educational materials about each style of cheese and recommended pairings; they even feature information on the cheesemakers themselves, providing a truly well-rounded cheese tasting experience. Cheese subscriptions may also offer early access to exclusive cheeses or other product discounts.

Can I Provide Any Personal Preferences for the Cheeses I Will Receive?

Typically cheese of the month clubs do not allow any modifications or substitutions because their selections are chosen in advance and are standardized for all subscribers. If you have strong dislikes for certain cheeses, we suggest opting for a program that has several club options (such as Murray's), or one where you can view the selections in advance (such as Harry & David), in case you want to skip that month's delivery.

Do Cheese of the Month Clubs Provide Cost Savings?

Cheese prices range considerably depending on a variety of factors including the type of cheese, region it is sourced from, whether it is fresh or aged, and if it meets any specific designation of origin standards such as with Parmigiano Reggiano. As noted above, cheese of the month clubs can range from $37 to $100 per month and will usually include a mix of both moderately priced and expensive cheeses.

How Much Cheese Comes in Each Subscription Box?

This will vary, but most include three types of cheese, ranging from ¼ lb. to ½ lb. each, totalling about 1.5 pounds per box. Please check specific subscriptions plans for details or contact customer service before you order.

Methodology

Nearly a dozen cheese of the month clubs were reviewed before making these final selections. The final list was chosen based on the mix of styles and regions of cheeses, featured cheesemakers, access to limited production cheeses, and supplemental education materials. We also looked at the user-friendliness of the subscription sign-up process and accessibility of customer service. Priority was given to subscriptions offering a complete experience rather than solely a shipment of cheeses.

Was this page helpful?
Related Articles