Forget the Turkey—These Thanksgiving Pie Deliveries Are So Irresistible, They'll Outshine the Main Course
Thanksgiving isn't complete without pie—you need something sweet to counterbalance the gravy-laden mashed potatoes, turkey, and stuffing from previous courses. However, we also understand that you might not feel up to making dessert from scratch after a marathon of cooking. That's why we're giving you full permission to order pie online. Bakeries and dessert shops from all over the country can deliver their best flavors to your front door, so you can order your favorite pie no matter the distance between you and the baker. Stock your Thanksgiving dessert table with classic flavors like pumpkin pie and apple pie, but don't forget to try renowned pies like key lime pie from Kermit's Key West in Florida or a multi-layered pie from PieCaken Bake Shop.
We've included some of our favorites in this roundup—all you have to do is pick which one (or two or three) you want to serve.
Best Pies to Order for Thanksgiving 2021
- Best Apple Pie: Little Pie Company
- Best Pecan Pie: Sweetie Pies Bakery
- Best Sweet Potato Pie: Dangerously Delicious Pies
- Best Pumpkin Pie: Harry & David
- Best Key Lime Pie: Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shop
- Best Pie Crust: The Elegant Farmer
- Best Blueberry Pie: Two Fat Cats Bakery
- Best Cherry Pie: Petee's Pie Company
- Best Coconut Cream Pie: Betty's Pies
- Best Strawberry Rhubarb Pie: The Chocolate Maven
- Best Peach Pie: Harry & David
- Best Pie Cake: PieCaken Bakeshop
- Best Chocolate Pecan Pie: Three Brothers Bakery
- Best Berry Pie: Achatz Handmade Pie Co.
- Best Cookie Pie: Milk Bar
- Best S'Mores Pie: Butter & Scotch
- Best Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie: Tate's Bake Shop
- Best Crumble Topping: Grand Traverse Pie Company
- Best Caramel Apple Pie: Blue Owl Bakery
- Best Marionberry Pie: Willamette Valley Pie Company
- Best Fudge Pie: Collin Street Bakery
Best Apple Pie: Little Pie Company
Founded by a Broadway actor in 1985, this pastry shop in New York City quickly became a highly acclaimed location to find delicious handmade pies. Three decades later, Little Pie Company continues to make irresistible pies in an array of flavors, receiving accolades from food critics and loyal customers alike. One of its most popular offerings is the sour cream apple walnut pie, which folds brown sugar and cinnamon in amongst layers of Granny Smith apple slices.
To buy: Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie, $69; goldbelly.com
Best Pecan Pie: Sweetie Pies Bakery
Another classic Thanksgiving pie that's bound to be a crowd pleaser, this pecan pie from Sweetie Pies Bakery has a smooth textured filling with a crispy top. It's made with maple syrup and topped with toasted pecans for a rich caramel finish, so it's the ideal sweet treat after platefuls of turkey and mashed potatoes. The bakery recommends enjoying your slice of pecan pie with a dollop of whipped cream or vanilla ice cream for even more sweetness.
To buy: Pecan Pie, $69; goldbelly.com
Best Sweet Potato Pie: Dangerously Delicious Pies
The humble sweet potato has never tasted better than it does in this handcrafted pie. Dangerously Delicious Pies in Baltimore, Maryland, is known for its traditional holiday pies, like sweet potato pie, in addition to savory flavors, like the steak and mushroom gruyere pie. Made from locally sourced ingredients and loaded with sweet potatoes, sugar, and spices, the sweet potato pie has all the rich flavor you'd expect from the classic Southern dessert. The 10-inch handmade pie serves as many as eight people, so you and your holiday guests can each enjoy a slice.
To buy: Sweet Potato Pie, $65; goldbelly.com
Best Pumpkin Pie: Harry & David
No Thanksgiving spread is quite complete without pumpkin pie, and this deep-dish version from Harry & David is so delicious that you'll be tempted to skip right over the turkey. Made from real pumpkins and baked inside a flaky crust, this enticing pie is topped with whipped cream and dusted in pumpkin pie spice. Harry & David offers express shipping on this classic holiday dessert, making it even easier to ensure your pie arrives in time for the festivities.
To buy: Deep Dish Pumpkin Pie, $60; harryanddavid.com
Best Key Lime Pie: Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shop
As the weather gets cooler, take your taste buds on vacation off the coast of Florida with the help of this delicious Key lime pie. Located on the historic Key West Bight, Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shop is renowned for its key lime pies with delightful graham cracker crust and tart, fluffy filling. The pies are made using the shop's famous Key lime juice and dolloped with whipped cream for a light dessert that's just as beautiful as it is delicious.
To buy: Kermit's Key West Key Lime Pie, $79; goldbelly.com
Best Pie Crust: The Elegant Farmer
The secret to this apple pie's perfectly crispy, flaky crust lies in the unconventional way it's baked: inside a paper bag. The country-style pie is first piled high with steamed Ida Red apples, sealed beneath a delicious sugar cookie crust, and then baked inside a simple paper bag. As it cooks, the inside of the pie becomes sweet, the bottom crust remains buttery, and the top crust transforms into a uniquely crunchy layer that's hard to resist. Order your own paper bag-baked pie from The Elegant Farmer, which offers its apple pie, blueberry apple pie, rhubarb-apple pie, and caramel apple pie for nationwide delivery on Goldbelly.
To buy: Apple Pie Baked in a Paper Bag, $60; goldbelly.com
Best Blueberry Pie: Two Fat Cats Bakery
This from-scratch bakery in Portland, Maine, has been specializing in baked sweets made with real butter, locally sourced eggs, and wild Maine blueberries since 2005. Founded on the belief that good pies come from high-quality ingredients, Two Fat Cats Bakery hand-makes each of its delicious pies and delivers them nationally through Goldbelly. Try the shop's popular blueberry pie, which is packed with wild Maine blueberries and tossed with sugar and spices to bring out the bright berry flavors. We also recommend topping a warm slice with a big scoop of vanilla ice cream to serve.
To buy: Maine Wild Blueberry Pie, $59; goldbelly.com
Best Cherry Pie: Petee's Pie Company
Petra, the founder of Petee's Pie Company, grew up in a family of pie makers and learned all the secrets to creating a perfect pie from a young age. All that knowledge culminated in 2014 when Petra opened her own pie shop in New York City, and ever since then, her handmade pies have been highly praised by nearly everyone who's tried them. The New York sour cherry pie is one of Petee's most popular flavors, and it's made from scratch using locally sourced tart red cherries and natural fair-trade sweeteners. You can choose between a 6-inch pie that serves two to three people or a 9-inch pie that serves six to eight guests. Simply pop this ready-to-bake pie into your oven, then taste test it with your Thanksgiving guests.
To buy: New York Sour Cherry Pie, From $45; goldbelly.com
Best Coconut Cream Pie: Betty's Pies
A quaint fish shack in Two Harbors, Minnesota, is probably the last place you'd expect to find a booming pie business, but that's exactly where Betty's Pies got its start. After realizing the fishermen who visited her father's fishing shack in the 1950s might enjoy a sweet dessert, Betty began serving homemade pies that quickly surged in popularity. Today, Betty's Pie Shop is a destination in and of itself, with visitors from all across the United States popping in to try a slice. You can order one for your Thanksgiving table this year, including the coconut cream pie, which boasts a fluffy coconut custard cream sprinkled with toasted coconut.
To buy: Coconut Cream Pie, $49; goldbelly.com
Best Strawberry Rhubarb Pie: The Chocolate Maven
Enjoy sweet, summery pie flavors any time of year by ordering a tart strawberry rhubarb pie that's been baked beneath a stunning lattice top crust. The Chocolate Maven, an artisan pastry shop located in New Mexico, has been cooking up wholesome meals, baked goods, and crave-worthy sweet treats in Santa Fe for over 50 years. Made from consciously sourced ingredients, the shop's signature pies feature plump fruits, like blueberries, blackberries, peaches, and more. Try the strawberry rhubarb pie, which combines tangy and sweet flavors inside a handmade pie crust and can be shipped nationally. You can even opt for a vegan version of this pie, which excludes the shiny egg wash found on top of many pastries.
To buy: Strawberry Rhubarb Pie, $18; thechocolatemaven.com
Best Peach Pie: Harry & David
For a pie with bright, fruit-forward flavors, try this deep-dish option from Harry & David. The country-style peach and berry pie is filled with peaches, blueberries, and raspberries in a crisp pastry shell. Instead of a double crust or lattice top, the pie is generously sprinkled with a cinnamon-and-sugar streusel, making for a dessert that's (almost) too beautiful to eat.
To buy: Peach and Berry Pie, $40; harryanddavid.com
Best Pie Cake: PieCaken Bakeshop
What's better than a slice of pie? Two slices of pie layered beneath a slice of cake, called the PieCaken. This show-stopping dessert quickly caught the attention of celebrities and food critics alike when PieCaken Bakeship first created it in 2015, and it even caused a pumpkin puree shortage in New York City that same year due to its success. Thanks to Goldbelly, you don't have to make a trip to the Big Apple to secure your dessert; simply get it delivered to your doorstep. The PieCaken is made up of three irresistible layers: pecan pie, then pumpkin pie, and finally spice cake on top, with cinnamon buttercream separating each layer. Topped with apple pie filling, this multi-layered dessert is an impressive addition to your Thanksgiving menu and serves 12–16 people.
To buy: PieCaken, $99; goldbelly.com
Best Chocolate Pecan Pie: Three Brothers Bakery
For sweet caramel pecan flavors swirled together with rich chocolate tones, try a chocolate pecan pie from Three Brothers Bakery. The Polish bakery was founded in 1949, and since then, it has gained recognition for its deep dish pies and innovative multi-layered pumpecapple piecake. The rich and gooey chocolate pecan pies made by Three Brothers Bakery truly stand out, made with chocolate chips, crisp pecans, and delicious fudge. You can even try the chocolate bourbon pecan pie, which uses Jack Daniels whiskey in its secret recipe.
To buy: Chocolate Pecan Pies, from $59; goldbelly.com
Best Berry Pie: Achatz Handmade Pie Co.
As a National Pie Championship winner, the crumb Michigan four-berry pie is too delicious not to be included on your Thanksgiving table. Loaded with locally grown cherries, blueberries, raspberries, and blackberries, this tart-yet-sweet pie is handmade in Armada, Michigan, before being carefully shipped to your doorstep. The Achatz family has been making award-winning pies since 1993, and many of their recipes have been perfected over several generations, meaning the flavorful berry pie you receive is the product of decades of care and tradition.
To buy: Crumb Michigan Four-Berry Pie, $54; goldbelly.com
Best Cookie Pie: Milk Bar
Milk Bar's signature pie is popular for a reason—this decadent dessert features a buttery, salty-yet-sweet filling and a crust made out of oat cookies. Similar to the classic Southern chess pie, it's made out of simple ingredients like butter, sugar, and eggs, but the end result has customers across the country raving. With nearly 2,500 ratings and an overall four out of five star rating, the Milk Bar pie is sure to be a hit at your Thanksgiving celebration.
To buy: Milk Bar Pie, $46; milkbarstore.com
Best S'mores Pie: Butter & Scotch
For a pie that's reminiscent of a crackling bonfire on a cool autumn day, try ordering a s'mores pie from Butter & Scotch. The famous pie has all the elements of a perfectly gooey s'more, with a crispy graham cracker crust, chocolate custard filling, and a torched marshmallow top. This dessert can be served cold, but for an even more authentic flavor, you can pop the pie into the broiler for one or two minutes to crisp the marshmallow coating.
To buy: S'mores Pie, $42; butterandscotch.com
Best Crumble Topping: Grand Traverse Pie Company
Add a pop of color to your Thanksgiving menu with these bright fruit pies sealed beneath an irresistible crumble topping. Grand Traverse Pie Company has several delightful flavors to choose from, like cherry crumb pie, strawberry-rhubarb crumb pie, blueberry crumb pie, and apple crumb pie. The pies are made from locally sourced ingredients and hand-rolled for the perfect flaky crust base, then sprinkled with crumb topping. While we know picking a favorite flavor out of Grand Traverse Pie Company's impressive lineup will be difficult, there's no rule that says you can't order more than one.
To buy: Grand Traverse Pie Company Crumb Pies, from $59; goldbelly.com
Best Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie: Tate's Bake Shop
Tate's Bake Shop may have just achieved the impossible: making a dessert even more delicious than a batch of homemade cookies. The bakery's chocolate chip cookie pie has the crispy-on-the-outside, gooey-on-the-inside texture we all love about our go-to cookie recipes, combined with a flaky pie crust. Try this pie fresh out of the oven with a scoop of vanilla ice cream on top—you won't regret it.
To buy: Chocolate Chip Pie, $32; tatesbakeshop.com
Best Caramel Apple Pie: Blue Owl Bakery
Wow your Thanksgiving dinner guests with this gravity-defying apple pie from Blue Owl Bakery. The Levee high caramel pecan apple pie is approximately 9 inches tall, filled with 18 hand-peeled Golden Delicious apples, and topped with a caramelly made-from-scratch crust. It arrives fully assembled and ready to bake in your own oven, so you can enjoy the heavenly smells that'll waft through your kitchen as it bakes. Plus, Oprah named the Levee high caramel pecan apple pie one of her favorite things in 2011, so you know it's bound to be delicious. The pie serves 10–12 people, so there'll be plenty to share with Thanksgiving guests.
To buy: Levee High Caramel Pecan Apple Pie, $109; goldbelly.com
Best Marionberry Pie: Willamette Valley Pie Company
Grown exclusively in the state of Oregon, marionberries are a cross between two different types of blackberries and offer a tart, earthy flavor that makes them perfect for pies. Willamette Valley Pie Company has been locally growing berries since 1999, transforming the fruit into delightfully sweet pies using family recipes and all-natural ingredients. Choose between the classic marionberry pie, which features a hand-shaped crust, or order the marionberry crunch pie, which combines the tart berry flavor with a buttery almond crumble topping.
To buy: Marionberry Pie, $69; goldbelly.com
Best Fudge Pie: Collin Street Bakery
Though this Corsicana, Texas-based bakery is world famous for its holiday fruitcakes, Collin Street Bakery also makes a mean chocolate fudge pie. This dessert is made with whole eggs and semi-sweet chocolate, then baked inside a deep-dish crust until the top takes on the crackly consistency of a brownie. Try the original chocolate fudge pie, or order a deep-dish fudge pecan pie that's been topped with toasted pecans to combine two classic holiday sweets into one.
To buy: Fudge Pie, from $22; collinstreet.com
