Gail Simmons' Favorite Desserts

By Food & Wine
Updated May 05, 2017
Credit: © Con Poulos
These tasty recipes include honeyed fig crostatas and banana pudding with a vanilla wafer crumble.
Start Slideshow

1 of 22

Towering Coconut Layer Cake

Credit: PHOTO © JOHN KERNICK
Go to Recipe

Because Tyler Florence wanted his Wayfare Tavern to feel like a century-old San Francisco institution, he researched menus dating all the way back to the Gold Rush. This cake couldn't be more traditional: four layers of rum-brushed yellow cake filled and frosted with a light and airy, coconut-scented meringue-buttercream.

Advertisement
Advertisement

2 of 22

Bittersweet Chocolate Mousse

Credit: © Stephanie Foley
Go to Recipe

Ad Hoc's chef de cuisine Dave Cruz created this rich chocolate mousse as a refined homage to the pudding he loved as a child. At the restaurant he serves it simply, but it's also wonderful garnished with giant curls of bittersweet chocolate made with a vegetable peeler.

3 of 22

Rich and Creamy Butterscotch Pudding

Go to Recipe

One good store-bought caramel sauce is the Burnt Caramel Sauce from Recchiuti Confections.

Advertisement

4 of 22

Frozen Maple-Mousse Pie with Candied Cranberries

Go to Recipe

Kathleen Callahan of Seattle’s Emmer & Rye started her career studying marine biology, then segued into cooking fish in restaurants. Her latest move was to the pastry kitchen; she decided it would be much more pleasant to "smell like vanilla at the end of my shift." Today she makes delicious desserts like this frozen pie topped with slow-simmered cranberries.

5 of 22

Lemon Ice Box Pie

Credit: © Taunton Press
Go to Recipe

This silken frozen pie is adapted from Clancy’s, one of David Guas’s favorite New Orleans neighborhood restaurants.

6 of 22

Fudgy Chocolate-Walnut Cookies

Credit: © Quentin Bacon
Go to Recipe

New York pastry chef François Payard’s divinely gooey chocolate cookies are flourless.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

7 of 22

Honeyed Fig Crostatas

Go to Recipe

Pair with a subtly sweet sparkling wine.

8 of 22

Butterscotch Pots de Crème with Caramel Sauce

Go to Recipe

"I have a lot of guys from Oaxaca in my kitchen, and they put salt on everything," says Travis Lett. "When I saw one of them add salt to this dessert, I thought, Hey, that’s a great idea."

9 of 22

Chocolate–Peanut Butter Moon Pies

Credit: Photo © Con Poulos
Go to Recipe

Moon pies are classic Southern cookies filled with marshmallow and coated with chocolate. Rebekah Turshen, the pastry chef at Nashville’s City House, models hers on the classic, but also on the excellently named Goo-Goo Clusters, a peanut candy invented in Nashville in 1912. She spreads crispy sugar cookies with chocolate and peanut butter, then sandwiches them around a marshmallow filling.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

10 of 22

Mango-Basil Vacherin

Credit: © Kate Mathis
Go to Recipe

Yigit Pura perfected this crisp-creamy French dessert while working at restaurant Daniel in New York City. His updated version combines little lime meringue kisses with basil ice cream and sweet mango sorbet.

11 of 22

Banana Pudding with Vanilla Wafer Crumble

Credit: © Taunton Press
Go to Recipe

David Guas remembers this comforting dessert from the buffet spreads at family funerals.

12 of 22

Almond, Elderflower and Lime Travel Cakes

Credit: © Kate Mathis
Go to Recipe

Inspired by French travel cakes (small sweets meant for bringing to parties, picnics and other events), William Werner created these miniature desserts. He calls them "gussied-up pound cakes."

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

13 of 22

Halvah-Sesame Sundae

Credit: © Marcus Nilsson/"The Perfect Finish"
Go to Recipe

The sesame-flavored ice cream for this sundae is fun and unique, but store-bought vanilla ice cream is delicious, too.

14 of 22

Chilled Grapefruit-Caramel Meringue Pie

Credit: © Tina Rupp
Go to Recipe

Most pastry chefs love lemon and orange. Deborah Snyder of Manhattan's Lever House, however, champions the also-ran of the citrus world: grapefruit. In one cold, creamy dessert, she layers pink grapefruit curd in a crunchy graham-cracker crust with caramel sauce and a delicate topping of fluffy meringue.

15 of 22

Chocolate-Peanut-Butter-Banana Upside-Down Cake

Credit: © Burcu Avsar
Go to Recipe

Grace Parisi uses one of the world's great flavor combinations for her unusual marble cake topped with bananas, which caramelize on the bottom of the pan (ideally a glass one).

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

16 of 22

Butterscotch-Glazed Coffee Shortbread Bars

Go to Recipe

Flo Braker flavors her ethereally light shortbread with finely ground espresso beans. The best part is the golden, gooey butterscotch glaze, which becomes deliciously fudgy as the bars sit in the cookie jar.

17 of 22

Linzer Cookies with Spiced Jam

Credit: PHOTO © JOHN KERNICK
Go to Recipe

Kevin Sbraga credits his father, Harvey Beachem, with creating these linzer torte-inspired cookies at Harvey's Bakery in Willingboro, New Jersey. He takes his father's recipe one step further, adding anise and coriander to the raspberry jam that he spreads between the hazelnut cookies (which are spiced with cinnamon and cloves).

18 of 22

Revelatory Caramel Cake

Credit: © Angie Mosier
Go to Recipe

This amazing cake comes from chef Ann Cashion of Washington, DC, restaurant Johnny's Half Shell.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

19 of 22

Coconut Arborio Rice Pudding

Go to Recipe

Arborio rice is great for Stephanie Prida's pudding, because the plump grains stay perfectly firm and chewy.

20 of 22

Orange-Cardamom Date Bars with a Nutty Crust

Credit: © Frances Janisch
Go to Recipe

The crunchy, almondy topping for these clever bars is loaded with vitamin E. The filling is chewy like caramel and is full of vitamin C from the orange.

21 of 22

Caramel Cream Pie with Crispy Rice Topping

Credit: © Frances Janisch
Go to Recipe

Humble ingredients like puffed rice cereal (transformed into a brilliant topping) and graham crackers (crushed with hazelnuts to yield a tender crust) are the core of this surprisingly luxe dessert.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

22 of 22

Minny's Chocolate Pie

Credit: © Con Poulos
Go to Recipe

The Help’s ending hinges on a secret involving Minny’s famous chocolate pie. Newspaper columnist Lee Ann Flemming, one of the best bakers in Greenwood, made 53 chocolate pies during filming, including 12 vegan and gluten-free versions she prepared in just one day for actress Bryce Dallas Howard. Her fudgy version here is neither vegan nor gluten-free: It’s as classic as it gets. You can make your own crust, but Flemming uses packaged.

Replay gallery

Share the Gallery

Up Next

By Food & Wine