What’s Included in a Baking Subscription Box?

Usually, you’ll receive everything you need except perishable items, such as butter, milk, eggs, and the like. You’ll also need to use your own baking equipment , such as baking sheets, mixers, baking pans, etc. Many companies even include tools or equipment, such as parchment paper, cupcake liners, or other special extras like sprinkles.

Are Baking Subscription Boxes Customizable?

Many of them can be customized, especially if you send them as a gift. The Cookie Crate, for example, lets you choose among its dozen and a half varieties, or you can choose a curated gift set for specific occasions.

Are Baking Subscription Boxes Good for Experienced Bakers?

Baking boxes are great for people who like to bake, regardless of skill set. Some are geared toward kids, such as Baketivity, or beginners, such as Bake Eat Love. There’s something for everyone, and while you might be experienced with baking sweets , you may want to learn how to bake bread , for example. There’s always something to learn, and baking subscription boxes can make the process enjoyable.

Do Baking Subscription Boxes Come With Baking Utensils?

Some of them do, but in most cases, you’ll need your own spatulas, whisks, bowls, stand mixer, etc., along with other equipment . Read the fine print closely, however, because some companies sell equipment in addition to their boxes (see Baketivity), but others don’t.

Best Baking Subscription Boxes of 2023

We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation. Learn more.

Do you like to bake but find it difficult to create time for it? Or maybe you need some inspiration or want to learn how to make a wide variety of baked goods. If you like to bake, or you’re just starting out, or maybe you want to learn how to bake bread, for example, baking boxes can make it happen on a regular basis. We found the best baking subscription boxes no matter what your interest or skill set.

Best Baking Subscription Boxes of 2023

Best Variety: Homemade Bakers Club
Best for Beginners: Bake Eat Love
Best for Cookie Dough: Doughp
Best for Bread Baking: Breadista
Best for Kids: Baketivity
Best for Prebaked Cookies: The Cookie Crate
Best for Dessert Lovers: Red Velvet

Best Variety: Homemade Bakers Club

Homemade Bakers Club

Learn More

Key Specs

Starting Price: $31 per month
Ingredients included: Yes, nonperishables
Dietary Modifications Available: No

Why You Should Try It

For the widest variety of baking projects at a reasonable price point, Homemade Bakers Club keeps its offerings simple and straightforward with baking kits you’ll want to dive into immediately.

Pros and Cons

Pros

Dessert and bread-baking options
Easy to skip a month or substitute with cinnamon rolls
Lots of online tutorials, including videos

Cons

Options for one-time purchases sell out fast
Perishable items needed for seasonal recipes

Overview

Homemade Bakers Club is a great way to start if you are new to baking boxes. You can bake almost any sweet treat with this subscription (or a one-off purchase). Whether it’s creative versions of cupcakes, cookies, or brownies, or savory options such as focaccia, pizza dough, challah bread, or garlic knots, the Mix Box has you covered. Everything you need regarding dry ingredients and equipment (think cupcake liners, parchment paper, toothpicks, etc.) shows up in the box monthly. Reminder emails ahead of your delivery are a nice touch; they help you prep your grocery list for the perishable ingredients you’ll need.

Pricing and Plans

You can order a one-time box or subscribe to receive boxes every month. Mix boxes ship around the 7th of the month. If you’re not psyched about the monthly selection, you can opt for a swap box (usually the cinnamon buns) or skip a month.

Monthly shipments: $33 on a month-to-month basis.
Three months for $96 (or $32 per month).
Six months for $186 (or $31 per month).

Best for Beginners: Bake Eat Love

Learn More

Key Specs

Starting Price: $40 per month
Ingredients Included: Yes, nonperishables
Dietary Modifications Available: Yes

Why You Should Try It

For those who are starting out with baking or who want to introduce children to the art, Bake Eat Love’s kits send you everything you need except eggs, milk, and butter.

Pros and Cons

Pros

All dry ingredients included
Variety of baking projects to choose from
Free shipping

Cons

Only one gluten-free kit available
Projects aren’t necessarily basic

Overview

It can be daunting when you’re just starting out with a new hobby, especially a culinary one. Bake Eat Love is great because its kits, which you can order individually or via a monthly subscription, provide you with everything you need for dry, premeasured ingredients: flour, sugar, baking soda, etc. The company also includes video tutorials for on-the-spot help and email support for questions you can’t seem to get answered elsewhere. Recipe cards are easy to follow, too, and the company’s blog offers plenty of info and support.

Baking kits include seasonal favorites like chocolate peppermint whoopie pies, pumpkin cake pops, and other goodies. The kits are well thought out and sophisticated for beginners but achievable. If you’re looking for something to guide you through a basic cake, cookie, or pie making, this may not be the approach. But for a completed start-to-finish dessert that you’d be happy to bring to the table, Bake Eat Love delivers, and you’ll learn valuable techniques along the way, too, whether it’s working with egg whites (raspberry and orange French macarons) or how to flambé (bananas foster sticky buns).

Pricing and Plans

Some others are more comprehensive and involved, such as the International Baking kit bundle, which starts at $116 and includes three baking projects: Italian-inspired tiramisu cupcakes, Brazilian cookies (briagdeiros) and Argentinian cookies (alfajores), and Japanese-inspired yuzu lava cakes. You can skip or cancel subscriptions at any time or order individually. Either way, shipping is free.

Best for Cookie Dough: Doughp

Doughp

Learn More

Key Specs

Starting Price: $30 per month
Ingredients Included: Yes
Dietary Modifications Available: No

Why You Should Try It

Doughp ships you premade cookie dough in quirkily named flavors that you’ll love, but we also love its commitment to mental health and recovery outreach efforts.

Pros and Cons

Pros

Can eat raw or baked
Can be refrigerated or frozen
Super friendly customer service

Cons

Small size
A bit pricey for what you get

Overview

This company with a conscience was born out of the solace its founder discovered in the kitchen during her recovery and has been featured on Shark Tank twice. Fun flavors include Ride or Die (chocolate chip, naturally); Cookie Monsta, a cookie whose blue hue resembles Cookie Monster from Sesame Street; and Fairy Dust, which is like a sugar cookie dotted with a riot of sprinkles. The coolest part? The dough can be eaten raw or baked, thanks to its eggless formula and heat-treated flour, taking away any danger associated with eating cookie dough. (Note: the dough is not gluten-free or vegan, however.)

People also love the 100% money-back guarantee, which isn’t something you can always find with food delivery services. Doughp offers cookie dough in containers that resemble ice cream pints and cookie dough “drops” that are bite size and very easily consumable as is or to plop right onto a waiting baking sheet. The dough comes in 8-ounce containers, yielding about 15 cookies (or 27 spoonfuls). Dough “drops” come in about 30 to a 10-ounce package.

Pricing and Plans

There are several ways to get your cookie dough fix from Doughp.

Individual 8-ounce containers of cookie dough: $9.
Cookie Dough Drops: $12 for 10-ounce package.
Monthly boxes start at 4 for $50, and you can mix and match dough drops and dough containers.
Secret Cookie Dough club is $30 for two 8-ounce cups sent monthly with free shipping. You receive unique rotating and secret/new flavors before they’re released to the public.
Other “packs” of four types of cookie dough can be shipped monthly ($45) as a subscription, or as a one-time purchase ($50).

Best for Bread Baking: Breadista

Breadista

Learn More

Key Specs

Starting Price: $45 per month
Ingredients Included: Yes, nonperishables
Dietary Modifications Available: No

Why You Should Try It

For the aspiring bread baker or someone who wants foolproof recipes to add to their bread-baking repertoire, Breadista brings you European-style recipes every month.

Pros and Cons

Pros

Organic ingredients prioritized when possible
European-style bread at home
Recipes will work in any oven

Cons

Not tested or designed for bread machines
More expensive

Overview

Breadista leans heavily on German-style breads, such as Dinkelweck (a German spelt roll) and Almweck (German rye and spice), but you can find French, Swiss, and Italian styles, too, and classics you didn’t know you wanted to make, such as English muffins.

You’ll only need water, olive oil, or butter for most recipe boxes; otherwise, everything is included in the kit. Breadista gives you smart recommendations, such as using filtered water (it has a softer taste) or bottled water. The website is also full of helpful tips about using a Dutch oven, baking steel, spray bottle, and other tricks to make the best bread possible.

Pricing and Plans

One-time purchase: $45
3-month subscription: $138
6-month subscription: $269

Best for Kids: Baketivity

Learn More

Key Specs

Starting Price: $35 per month
Ingredients Included: Yes, nonperishables
Dietary Modifications Available: Yes

Why You Should Try It

Kids who are curious about baking will enjoy the baking kits from Baketivity, which aims to teach children valuable kitchen skills while making the learning process fun.

Pros and Cons

Pros

Kid-friendly recipes
Colorful, illustrated instructions
Gluten-free kits available

Cons

Recipes are basic
Kits are not nut-free

Overview

Baketivity is geared toward kids ages 4 through 10 and comes with step-by-step instructions to bake everything from chocolate chunk cookies and granola bars to bagels and cinnamon buns. Seasonal offerings pop up around holidays.

We like Baketivity because you can also buy other useful, kid-friendly supplies, such as a kid-safe knife set, baking kit, or cupcake pans. Other fun options include a dog treat or themed kits, including beach day cupcakes, earth compost cookie baking kits, etc. Kits also include a chef hat and apron and monthly achievement stickers so children can celebrate their progress.

Pricing and Plans

One-time purchases vary in price, starting from $30 for a cake pop kit, for example, or $46 for a kids’ birthday cake kit. Subscriptions are also available and make good gifts, too. Shipping is free.

Month to month: $35
3-month subscription: $66 ($33 per month)
6-month subscription: $185 ($31 per month)
12-month subscription: $347 ($29 per month)

Best for Prebaked Cookies: The Cookie Crate

Learn More

Key Specs

Starting Price: $45 per box
Ingredients Included: N/A
Dietary Modifications Available: Yes

Why You Should Try It

If you need to send cookies as a gift, or are just craving a batch for yourself, The Cookie Crate offers a wide selection and bakes and ships its cookies on the same day.

Pros and Cons

Pros

Large selection of baked cookies
Two-day shipping
Gluten-free options

Cons

You shop by occasion, not by cookie flavors, which is a little confusing
No subscriptions available

Overview

Freshness is of the utmost importance when it comes to prebaked cookies, and Cookie Crate delivers. Offering about a dozen and a half flavors, it aims to add a new flavor a month and periodically offers limited editions to keep things interesting. Classic flavors like peanut butter, chocolate chip, sugar, and oatmeal raisin are available, along with creative ones, including 80 Beer (designed to be like Harry Potter’s Butter Beer in flavor) and Couch Potato, which includes cereal, potato chips, pretzels, and chocolate chips. You shop on this site by occasion and then choose the cookies you want from the drop-down menu, which includes at least a half dozen flavors and about five gluten-free options, which is refreshing.

Cookies will freeze for up to a month; they also can keep at room temperature for up to a week if stored in an airtight container. (Note: There’s even an option for nursing moms who might like the lactation cookies with brewer’s yeast and flaxseed.)

Pricing and Plans

Build a box from $45; includes a dozen cookies.
Discounts of 15% are available if you order three or more boxes. And while subscriptions aren’t offered per se, you can preorder cookies ahead of time, which is like a cross between a subscription and an on-the-spot order.

Best for Desserts: Red Velvet

Learn More

Key Specs

Starting Price: $49 per month
Ingredients Included: Yes, nonperishables
Dietary Modifications Available: Yes

Why You Should Try It

Red Velvet sends you the dry ingredients and easy-to-follow recipes you need to make truly elegant desserts.

Pros and Cons

Pros

Many decadent, French-inspired options
Can sort options based on skill level
Sells bakeware at a reasonable price

Cons

Limited number of cupcake options in comparison to cakes and cookies
Only one gluten-free/dairy-free item

Overview

There are a few ways to get your dessert fix from Red Velvet, a New York City-based baking outfit that leans heavily toward French patisserie in its vibe. A subscription sends you two of its baking kits per month, but you can also create one-time-only orders. Red Velvet’s overall selection is decadent and classy, with recipes for salted caramel brownies, Earl Grey tea cakes, French macarons with raspberry preserves, apple tartlets, and more. This is the baking kit you order when you need to serve an impressive dessert at a dinner party or want to create a gourmet confection.

Pricing and Plans

Monthly subscription: $49 with free shipping.
One-time shopping options start around $26 and go up to $34, depending on the item you select.
Orders over $75 ship for free.

Final Verdict

Kids can get started with flour and sugar using Baketivity’s kits. Fancy dessert needs can be satisfied with Red Velvet’s offerings. And if you’re looking for variety or want to finally master bread baking, we’ve got the best baking boxes for those options, too.

Compare the Best Baking Subscription Boxes

Company	Starting Price	Ingredients Included	Dietary Modifications Available	Free Shipping	Gift Options
Best Variety: Homemade Bakers Club	$31 per month	Yes, nonperishables	No	Yes	Yes
Best for Beginners: Bake Eat Love	$40 per month	Yes, nonperishables	Yes	Yes	Yes
Best for Cookie Dough: Doughp	$30 per month	Yes	No	Yes, for Secret Dough Club	Yes
Best for Bread Baking: Breadista	$45 per month	Yes, nonperishables	No	Yes for orders $85 and up	Yes
Best for Kids: Baketivity	$35 per month	Yes, nonperishables	Yes	Yes	Yes
Best for Prebaked Cookies: The Cookie Crate	$45 per box	N/A	Yes	No	Yes
Best for Desserts: Red Velvet	$49 per month	Yes, nonperishables	Yes	Yes, on orders $75 and up	Yes

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s Included in a Baking Subscription Box?

Usually, you’ll receive everything you need except perishable items, such as butter, milk, eggs, and the like. You’ll also need to use your own baking equipment, such as baking sheets, mixers, baking pans, etc. Many companies even include tools or equipment, such as parchment paper, cupcake liners, or other special extras like sprinkles.
Are Baking Subscription Boxes Customizable?

Many of them can be customized, especially if you send them as a gift. The Cookie Crate, for example, lets you choose among its dozen and a half varieties, or you can choose a curated gift set for specific occasions.
Are Baking Subscription Boxes Good for Experienced Bakers?

Baking boxes are great for people who like to bake, regardless of skill set. Some are geared toward kids, such as Baketivity, or beginners, such as Bake Eat Love. There’s something for everyone, and while you might be experienced with baking sweets, you may want to learn how to bake bread, for example. There’s always something to learn, and baking subscription boxes can make the process enjoyable.
Do Baking Subscription Boxes Come With Baking Utensils?

Some of them do, but in most cases, you’ll need your own spatulas, whisks, bowls, stand mixer, etc., along with other equipment. Read the fine print closely, however, because some companies sell equipment in addition to their boxes (see Baketivity), but others don’t.

Methodology

We wanted to offer a wide variety of options for baking boxes at home, whether you are new to baking, baking with a child, or looking to up your dessert game. We researched numerous online articles, reviews, and companies to find the best baking subscription boxes. There was much to consider: the types of recipes offered, the flexibility of the subscriptions, and the skill set or audience the services catered to. It was also important to consider how easy it was to use the kit; were the instructions clear, did the recipes work, and did they provide you with all the dry ingredients or supplies you needed? We also considered the creativity of the kits, the friendliness of customer service, and the ease of using a company’s website when making our recommendations.

Was this page helpful?