Advertisement Christmas Cookie Gift Tags Christmas Cookies 7 of 10 Photo © Seton Rossini. Decorating Supplies Now that the cookie “gift tags” have baked and cooled, it’s time to decorate! You’ll need to make a batch of royal icing and use food coloring. (Double this recipe.) GO TO RECIPE F&W’s Seton Rossini of the dessert blog Pixel Whisk explains how to make clever edible gift tags with a sugar cookie recipe.