27 Lobster & Surf Shack

Almondito

”At Almondito, a sleek new Mexican restaurant in Wainscott, a lot of sun-kissed women were stomping around in high heels;...”  More

Annona

”Italian spot opened above a luxury-car dealership....”  More

Annona

Besito

Bobby's Burger Palace

”The most popular is the Crunchburger, a beef patty topped with potato chips and a double serving of American cheese...”  More

Cyril's Fish House

”The meaty fried clams and the baked lobster stuffed with scallops and crab are great. But when I come to...”  More

Della Femina

Dock House, Sag Harbor

Duryea's

”Tables here are on a deck overlooking Fort Pond Bay—a spectacular place to see the sunset. It's BYOB, so bring...”  More

Fifth Season

”The bistro, warm with saffron-colored walls and exposed brick, pairs island produce (in dishes such as roast duck with cherry...”  More

Four Food Studio and Cocktail Salon

Fresno

”The most recent project from David Loewenberg (who co-owns another restaurant I love, Red/Bar Brasserie in Southampton), Fresno serves what...”  More

Frisky Oyster

”The lively bivalves here range from the local island variety to ones from as far away as Oregon. ...”  More

Gig Shack

”First came the fishermen. Then came the surfers. Now the formerly scruffy enclave of Montauk, at the easternmost point of...”  More

Gosman's Dock

Harvest on Fort Pond

Hideaway

”First came the fishermen. Then came the surfers. Now the formerly scruffy enclave of Montauk, at the easternmost point of...”  More

Home

”On Sunday, following a tip from David Page and Barbara Shinn, who own the restaurant Home in Manhattan and Shinn...”  More

Inlet Seafood

Jedediah Hawkins Inn

Joni's

”First came the fishermen. Then came the surfers. Now the formerly scruffy enclave of Montauk, at the easternmost point of...”  More

La Cuvée

”La Cuvée, with its wraparound windows, zinc bar and chartreuse chairs, feels as hip as anything in New York City....”  More

Lobster Roll Restaurant

Maguire Bayfront Restaurant

”Maguire Bayfront Restaurant, the old standby at the other end of the village, also has a dock. As kids, we...”  More

Marco

”I stop at Marco, an Italian restaurant near the harbor, for fresh mozzarella-and-tomato salad and snippets of conversation....”  More

Matthew's Seafood House

”On midsummer nights the crowds can be overwhelming, but the rest of the time, Ocean Beach is a sturdy little...”  More

Nick & Toni's

”When people say Nick & Toni's is fabulous, they're usually talking about the celeb-watching scene, not the menu. (Everyone from...”  More

North Fork Food

”North Fork Food, a sunny gourmet shop and café, is a perfect lunchtime stop for a bite on the shaded...”  More

North Fork Table & Inn

”The cod cake with black-truffled tartar sauce is as addictive as the warm cinnamon-cream doughnut holes....”  More

Ram's Head Inn

”The restaurant serves everything from omelettes to lobster to pistachio pie....”  More

Red bar Brasserie

Runaways Bar & Grill

”First came the fishermen. Then came the surfers. Now the formerly scruffy enclave of Montauk, at the easternmost point of...”  More

The Seafood Barge

”To my surprise and delight, chef Michael Meehan has fun with his fresh catch—since when can you get sushi at...”  More

Vine Street Café

”The chef-owners, alums of Manhattan's Union Square Café, rely on organic ingredients....”  More