27 Lobster & Surf Shack

Annona

Italian spot opened above a luxury-car dealership.... More

Annona

Cyril's Fish House

The meaty fried clams and the baked lobster stuffed with scallops and crab are great. But when I come to... More

Della Femina

Dock House, Sag Harbor

Duryea's

Tables here are on a deck overlooking Fort Pond Bay—a spectacular place to see the sunset. It's BYOB, so bring... More

Fresno

The most recent project from David Loewenberg (who co-owns another restaurant I love, Red/Bar Brasserie in Southampton), Fresno serves what... More

Gig Shack

First came the fishermen. Then came the surfers. Now the formerly scruffy enclave of Montauk, at the easternmost point of... More

Gosman's Dock

Harvest on Fort Pond

Hideaway

First came the fishermen. Then came the surfers. Now the formerly scruffy enclave of Montauk, at the easternmost point of... More

Inlet Seafood

Joni's

First came the fishermen. Then came the surfers. Now the formerly scruffy enclave of Montauk, at the easternmost point of... More

Lobster Roll Restaurant

Nick & Toni's

When people say Nick & Toni's is fabulous, they're usually talking about the celeb-watching scene, not the menu. (Everyone from... More

Red bar Brasserie

Runaways Bar & Grill

First came the fishermen. Then came the surfers. Now the formerly scruffy enclave of Montauk, at the easternmost point of... More