Alabama Jack's

Banana Café

Blond Giraffe

Blue Heaven Restaurant

In a former bordello allegedly frequented by Ernest Hemingway—hardly a unique claim in Key West—Blue Heaven is huge among the... More

BO's Fish Wagon

Café Marquesa

Adjoining the Marquesa Hotel, the café offers a dining room filled with sunshine during the day and illuminated by candles... More

Castaway

ChikiTiki Bar & Grille

Hidden away in a Marathon marina, ChikiTiki serves dockside grub with Mexican touches, such as a green-chile cheeseburger and spiced... More

Crack'd Conch

Fausto's

Fish House

The line is long, the conch chowder peppery, and the catch of the day done eight ways (try Matecumbe-style: tomatoes... More

Good Life

Hungry Tarpon

Little Palm Island

This bungalow set on a small private island has just 42 tables. Grab one and order the Ceviche, made with... More

Louie's Backyard

...Louie's maintains its status as an institution and is still a favorite among residents, despite the crush of tourists feasting... More

Mangrove Mattie's

Nine One Five

No Name Pub

This pub was established in 1935, which may be the last time it got a thorough cleaning. At least the... More

Pierre's

Sat on a balcony watching the sun set over the ocean and ate a delightful open-faced ravioli with Thai curry... More

Rooftop Cafe