Tested and Perfected by Food and Wine
Cocktail Recipe: The Witches’ Coffee
© Lucas Allen

The Witches' Coffee

  • SERVINGS: Makes 4 drinks

To underscore the rich flavor of dark Sumatra coffee, Bryan Dayton mixes it with aged rum, spicy, saffron-based Strega and molasses-y raw sugar. He even spices up the whipped cream, with bittersweet Italian Averna.

  1. 4 teaspoons Demerara or other raw sugar
  2. 12 ounces hot brewed coffee
  3. 6 ounces aged rum, preferably Ron Zacapa 23
  4. 3 ounces Strega (saffron-infused liqueur)
  5. Averna Cream (see Note), for garnish
  1. In a heatproof pitcher, stir the sugar into the coffee until dissolved, then stir in the rum and Strega. Pour the coffee into warmed mugs or heatproof glasses and spoon the Averna Cream on top.
Notes Averna Cream: In a medium chilled bowl, whip 4 ounces chilled heavy cream with 1 ounce Averna amaro and 1/2 tablespoon granulated sugar until soft peaks form. Use the cream immediately. Makes enough for 4 drinks.