Philadelphia's Best Sandwich Is Not a Cheesesteak

© Jason Varney

Philly's very name is synonymous with the cheesesteak, whose virtues are well-known and whose fans exhibit fervent loyalty; but the city's real sandwich of distinction is far less recognized.

"The Philadelphia roast pork is a much more complex and intriguing sandwich," says City Paper's food editor Caroline Russock. "Cheesesteaks are in-your-face obvious—meat and cheese and fat—but with the roast pork combo, there's a whole lot more going on, on a cerebral sandwich level."

The filling. Juicy roast pork, salted, simply seasoned and slow cooked. ("There's no shame in using dried ‘Italian' herbs," says Russock.) From there: cheese ("sharp provolone only, please"); charred long, hot peppers, and the most distinctive element: broccoli rabe, braised tender, appealingly bitter.

The bread. Italian rolls, consensus holds, that must come from the fifth-generation family bakery Sarcone's, in South Philly's Italian Market.

Where to get one:

DiNic's, the favorite of local chef Brad Spence, of Amis and Pizzeria Vetri. "It's a delicious textbook version." (Russock prefers the Navy Yard location.)

John's Roast Pork, endorsed by former Philly chef Ben Lee, now the executive chef at New York City's A Voce Madison: "The pork is juicy and tender," he says. That said, you'll find spinach here, rather than broccoli rabe—whether that's a step down is a matter of personal preference.

Nick's Old Original Roast Beef is Russock's choice: "bonus points for the windowless back bar dining room where you can grab a $2 lager."

Paesano's, the six-seat lunch counter at the original Girard Avenue location serves the Arista sandwich in the spirit of the Philly classic, but with meat from a roast whole suckling pig. Expect fall-apart pork, bits of crisp skin, provolone, broccoli rabe and long hots for a sandwich so lusciously rich it requires a stack of napkins to eat.

High Street on Market's Eli Kulp (formerly of Torrisi Italian Specialties in New York) modernizes the classic with broccoli rabe that's been lacto-fermented with garlic and chiles, similar to kimchi. The semolina rolls are baked on-site, and the heritage pork shoulder is cooked with onions, peppers and garlic over an eight-hour stint in a CVap oven, then quickly seared. Fermented chowchow and marinated cherry peppers are served on the table as garnish. The cheese? Regular sharp provolone. Sometimes you just can't improve on a classic.

Related: Philadelphia Food Obsessions
Philadelphia Food Tour with Kate Krader and Questlove
Philadelphia Travel Guide

DownComment IconEmail IconFacebook IconGoogle Plus IconGrid IconInstagram IconLinkedin IconList IconMenu IconMinus IconPinterest IconPlus IconRss IconSave IconSearch IconShare IconShopping Cart IconSpeech BubbleSnapchat IconTumblr IconTwitter IconWhatsapp IconYoutube Icon